1921. An innocent immigrant woman is tricked into a life of burlesque and vaudeville until a dazzling magician tries to save her and reunite her with her sister who is being held in the confines of Ellis Island.
I think this cartoon summarizes a pretty big portion of US history. People have been immigrating to the States since the very beginning of “US history”. Many Americans seem to forget that what they’re claiming immigrants are doing to the country now is not even comparable to what their ancestors have done to Native Americans. USA is sometimes referred to as “a nation built by immigrants” and I (with the knowledge I have gained from this course) couldn’t agree more. Sources say the percentage of immigrants in the States today is around 30. But at what point has an immigrant naturalized enough to not be considered an immigrant anymore? One way of looking at it is that immigrants make up nearly 97% of all US citizens.
Critical Response
“The Immigrant” is the least “historical” of movies we have watched so far, it is clearly more fiction-based.
“The Immigrant” tells the tragic story of a migrant who escapes one hardship and falls straight into another. It portrays the immigrant experience as a supposedly never-ending series of dehumanizing affairs. The director manages to create a very 20s-like atmosphere. With attention to little details such as accurately naming the town’s élite, the Fricks & the Vanderbilts, actually filming on Ellis island and showing a performance by Enrico Caruso, Gray makes you buy it. (However, for creating the atmosphere, credit should be given to the cinematographer and costume designer as well)
“There’s no romanticizing child labor or human trafficking or abject poverty. James Gray’s “The Immigrant” shows there’s also no romanticizing prostitution in New York City in 1921. “
The movie focuses more on prostitution than immigration (the title is rather misleading) but even so, it is quite accurate. Not many reviews talk about this side of the movie, considering how “the business of prostitution was thriving in the 1920’s, many prostitutes hung around saloons, nightclubs, and cabaret’s, many people also owned hidden brothels.“ And really, most of what we saw in the movie was based on the life of a prostitute. A parallel I found really intriguing was that in the first scene of the movie we see the statue of liberty from the viewpoint of an immigrant – the sign of making it and being able to start a new life. Not too much later, Ewa is shown dressed as lady liberty, putting on a show for the (local) men. Bandit’s Roost is a speakeasy (a bar during the prohibition era that sold alcohol illegally and got away with it by giving policemen discounts) – another example of the director paying attention to detail.
In conclusion, you can call the movie as boring, unrealistic and romanticized as you want when it comes to the plot, but you can’t ignore the effort the director put into researching the era.
Notions
The 19th century
Discovery of gold and gold mining
3 GOLD MAJOR FIRST GOLD RUSHES. North-Carolina, Georgia, California
- 1st rush in 1799 Gold discovered in North-Carolina. The finder didn’t know its value and used it as a doorstop. In 1802 it was recognized and word spread. First miners were FARMERS. Carolina mines evolved into mine-shafts. By 1835 there was a manifold of it so president Jackson created U.S mint to process it.
- 2nd rush (Georgia) in 1835 created tensions with aboriginals and resulted in the removal of Cherokee tribes from the area. Also a mint founded.
- 3rd rush In 1848, a gold mine in Coloma, California by J.W.Marshall. At first, tried to keep it a secret, didn’t succeed. Immigrants started flowing into California. ‘Forty-niners’ rushed to Calif. thanks to which it was made a state. Amateur and pro-miners. Private companies were created to process the gold=Entrepreneurship ‘flourished’.
The construction of railroads (Union Pacific Railroad Co, Central Pacific Railroad Co)
In 1862, a Pacific Railroad Act made 2 companies start building railroads that would connect the land from West to East. In 1869 the 2 sides met in Utah.
At first, people traveled from one coast to other usually by ship which took 6 months. Unless they were willing to go to the hazardous journey by foot, but people’s wish to travel increased with finding gold. Asa Whitney recommended building railroads. Engineer Theodor Judah made it happen after 20 years gaining the approval from Lincoln. The terms included that each company got 48k dollars for each mile which forced a competition early on. The construction companies included many megalomanian businessmen who also made illegal deals for profit. Native Americans feeling threatened of white Americans’ ‘iron horse’ attacked and kept disrupting the work. Poor settlements were founded behind the railroads forming the ‘Wild West’. Railorad constructers were different immigrants. The Union Pacific railroad company managed to cover 4 times as much distance as the Central Pacific one. 2 sides met in Promontory Summit.
Industrialisation (raw materials, effect on development of economy, main industries)
Process where an agricultural economy transforms into a manufacturing one. In USA it began in the early 1800s. After the Civil War, machines replaced much of the manual work. Industrialisation grew economy rapidly thanks to more goods being produced more quickly by machines. America had an abundance of natural resources; especially water helped to keep the machines working. Timber, iron, coal. Communication (telephones, railways, telegraph) helped businesses to succeed. New products such as photograph, telephone, typewriter. Many jobs in the manufactures to maximize efficiency in productivity. ‘Gilded era’-Mark Twain in 1920s-30; the culture of the new wealthy people building mansions and following Europe in its art design etc.
Formation of trusts
Trusts are formed when several businesses come together to standardize their rules and prices in order to increase profit. Great for businesses but bad for consumers. Trusts emerged when there rose a competition between different firms offering a similar product. Without trusts, companies would have to compete with each other which is not beneficial for either of them. Trusts helped to agree on rules so that no company would have to lower their prices. Famous trusts: Rockefeller’s Oil Trust, the Sugar Trust etc. Because of the negative effect on consumer (prices not lowering), acts were made by congress that would prohibit trusts.
(Stock-holders in a company who’d give their respective trustees the power to vote for decisions within the company. )
The role of Andrew Carnegie
American industrialist and philanthrophist. Worked in a Pittsburgh cotton factory (earning 1.20/week). Worked in Pennsylvania Railroad as the assistant to Thomas Scott, one of the railroad’s top officials. Became a superintendent of the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1859. Invested in iron and oil companies while working for the railroad. By 1889, he owned Carnegie Steel Corporation (largest steel company in the world). In 1901, he sold his business and dedicated his time to philanthrophy. Established the Carnegie-Mellon University in 1904
The role of John D. Rockefeller
founder of The Standard Oil Company (SOC) in 1870. Became one of the world’s wealthiest men, major philanthropist. Born in New York, entered the oil business by investing in a Cleveland refinery
SOC controlled 90% of US refineries. Was accused of colluding with railroads to eliminate his competitors. In 1911, US Supreme Court ordered SOC to be dissolved, in violation of anti-trust laws. During his life, he donated more than 500 million to philantrophy.
The role of Henry Ford
Grew up in Michigan, 1863. At the age of 16, left home for Detroit to work as a machinist. Returned home to work on the family farm after three year. In 1891, he went with his wife to Detroit. Was hired an engineer for the Edison Illuminating Company(EIC). Promoted chief engineer 2 years later. Spent many hours to build a gasoline-powered horseless carriage, or automobile. In 1896, completed the ‘’Quadricycle’’ – metal frame with 4 bicycle wheels powered by a gasoline engine. In 1902, established his Ford Motor Company. A month after, the first Ford car was assembled in Detroit (model T). Assembly process was slow and cars were built by hand. Ford introduced new mass-production methods, including large production plants, use of interchangeable parts and the world’s first moving assembly line for cars
Immigration to the US (my group)
Statue of Liberty
The Statue of Liberty (Liberty Enlightening the World; French: La Liberté éclairant le monde) is a colossal neoclassical sculpture on Liberty Island in New York Harbor in New York, in the United States. The copper statue standing at 93 meters, a gift from the people of France to the people of the United States, was designed by French sculptor Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi and its metal framework was built by Gustave Eiffel. The statue was dedicated on October 28, 1886. The Statue of Liberty is a figure of Libertas, a robed Roman liberty goddess. She holds a torch above her head with her right hand, and in her left hand carries a tabula ansata inscribed in Roman numerals with “JULY IV MDCCLXXVI” (July 4, 1776), the date of the U.S. Declaration of Independence. A broken chain lies at her feet as she walks forward. The statue became an icon of freedom and of the United States, and a national park tourism destination. It is a welcoming sight to immigrants arriving from abroad. Fundraising for the statue proved difficult, especially for the Americans, and by 1885 work on the pedestal was threatened by lack of funds. Publisher Joseph Pulitzer, of the New York World, started a drive for donations to finish the project and attracted more than 120,000 contributors, most of whom gave less than a dollar. Between 1886 and 1924, almost 14 million immigrants entered the United States through New York. The Statue of Liberty was a reassuring sign that they had arrived in the land of their dreams. To these anxious newcomers, the Statue’s uplifted torch did not suggest “enlightenment,” as her creators intended, but rather, “welcome.” Over time, Liberty emerged as the “Mother of Exiles,” a symbol of hope to generations of immigrants.
“The New Colossus” – Emma Lazarus
Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
MOTHER OF EXILES. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
“Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!” cries she
With silent lips. “Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
Causes of immigration from Europe in the 19th century
Fleeing crop failure, land and job shortages, rising taxes, and famine, many came to the U. S. because it was perceived as the land of economic opportunity. Others came seeking personal freedom or relief from political and religious persecution. More than 70 percent of all immigrants, however, entered through New York City, which came to be known as the “Golden Door.” Throughout the late 1800s, most immigrants arriving in New York entered at the Castle Garden depot near the tip of Manhattan.
A major wave of immigration occurred from around 1815 to 1865. Majority of the immigrants came from Northern and Western Europe.
- Approximately one-third came from IRELAND, which experienced a massive famine in the mid-19th century. In the 1840s, almost half of America’s immigrants were from Ireland alone. Typically impoverished, these Irish immigrants settled near their point of arrival in cities along the East Coast.
- Between 1820 and 1930, some 4.5 million Irish migrated to the United States.
Also in the 19th century, the United States received some 5 million GERMAN immigrants. Many of them journeyed to the present-day Midwest to buy farms or congregated in such cities as Milwaukee, St. Louis and Cincinnati. In the national census of 2000, more Americans claimed German ancestry than any other group. - During the mid-1800s, a significant number of ASIAN immigrants settled in the United States. Lured by news of the California gold rush, some 25,000 Chinese had migrated there by the early 1850s.
Between 1880 and 1920, a time of rapid industrialization and urbanization, America received more than 20 million immigrants. Beginning in the 1890s, the majority of arrivals were from Central, Eastern and Southern Europe.
- In that decade alone, some 600,000 ITALIANS migrated to America, and by 1920 more than 4 million had entered the United States.
- JEWS from Eastern Europe fleeing religious persecution also arrived in large numbers; over 2 million entered the United States between 1880 and 1920.
Different waves of immigration
(Colonial era)
First Wave 1790 – 1820
Groups of immigrants came for a variety of religious, political, and economic reasons. Northern and Western Europeans (English, Irish, Germans, Dutch, French, Spanish etc). Starvation, disease, and shipwreck killed 1 in 10 of those immigrants who set sail for America before they even set foot on land. (relatively little immigration, significant emigration to Canada)
Second Wave 1820 – 1860
Immigrants came for new opportunities because in Europe, peasants displaced from agriculture and artisans were made jobless from the industrial revolution. Some immigrants received “American Letters” which were encouraging friends and relatives to join them in America. German (escaping economic problems and seeking political freedom), British, Irish 40% (poverty and famine encouraged emigration). The Roman Catholic church was the single largest religious body in the United States by 1850.
Third Wave 1880 – 1914
Immigrants came over to America for more job opportunities and freedom of religion. Chinese, Japanese, and other Asian countries (migrated to the western states). In the 1910 census, foreign-born residents made up 15 percent of the U.S. population and 24 percent of the U.S. labor force.
Fourth Wave 1965 – Present
A new law that altered the selection of immigrants from the country they were from, to giving priority to people who already had family in the United States or had skills that were needed in the labor market. Europeans, Asians, Hispanics (Mexico). In the 1980s and early 1990s, Asians made up about one-third of the immigrants entering America. Hispanics made up about one-half of the number of immigrants in the 1980s and early 1990s.
Jewish immigration
Sephardic wave
The first group of Sephardic settlers arrived in New Amsterdam in 1654 from Brazil. For several decades afterward, adventurous Sephardic and Ashkenazic merchants established homes in American colonial ports, including Newport, R.I., New Amsterdam (later New York), Philadelphia, Charleston, S.C., and Savannah, Ga. This was a departure from the Old World, where synagogues in places like Amsterdam, London, and Recife, taxed commercial transactions, regulated Jewish publications, and punished members for lapses in individual or commercial morality.
German wave
German Jews began to come to America in significant numbers in the 1840s. Jews left Germany because of persecution, restrictive laws, economic hardship, and the failure of movements — widely supported by German Jews — advocating revolution and reform there. Some 250,000 German-speaking Jews came to America by the outbreak of World War I. This sizable immigrant community expanded American Jewish geography by establishing themselves in smaller cities and towns in the Midwest, West, and the South. If German Jews had one city of their own invention, it was Cincinnati.
Eastern European wave
Eastern European Jews began to immigrate to the United States in large numbers after 1880. Pushed out of Europe by overpopulation, oppressive legislation and poverty, they were pulled toward America by the prospect of financial and social advancement. Between 1880 and the onset of restrictive immigration quotas in 1924, over 2 million Jews from Russia, Austria-Hungary, and Romania came to America. The immigrants found work in factories, especially in the garment industry, but also in cigar manufacturing, food production, and construction. Large-scale Jewish immigration to the United States ended in 1924.
Ellis Island
On January 1, 1892 – her 15th birthday – Annie Moore from County Cork, Ireland, became the first person admitted to the new immigration station on Ellis Island. On that opening day, she received a greeting from officials and a $10.00 gold piece. Annie traveled to New York with her two younger brothers on steerage aboard the S.S. Nevada, which left Queenstown (now Cobh), Ireland, on December 20, 1891 and arrived in New York on the evening of December 31. After being processed, the children were reunited with their parents, who were already living in New York.
Ellis Island is a former immigration inspection station in New York Harbor, within the states of New York and New Jersey. It was the gateway for over 12 million immigrants to the United States as the nation’s busiest immigrant inspection station from 1892 until 1954. After an arduous sea voyage, immigrants arriving at Ellis Island were tagged with information from their ship’s registry; they then waited on long lines for medical and legal inspections to determine if they were fit for entry into the United States. From 1900 to 1914 – the peak years of Ellis Island’s operation – some 5,000 to 10,000 people passed through the immigration station every day.
Reed-Johnson Immigration Act of 1924
The Immigration Act of 1924 limited the number of immigrants allowed entry into the United States through a national origins quota. The quota provided immigration visas to two percent of the total number of people of each nationality in the United States as of the 1890 national census. It completely excluded immigrants from Asia. Signed into law by President Calvin Coolidge.
The 1924 Immigration Act also included a provision excluding from entry any alien who by virtue of race or nationality was ineligible for citizenship. Existing nationality laws dating from 1790 and 1870 excluded people of Asian lineage from naturalizing. As a result, the 1924 Act meant that even Asians not previously prevented from immigrating – the Japanese in particular – would no longer be admitted to the United States. Many in Japan were very offended by the new law, which was a violation of the Gentlemen’s Agreement. The Japanese government protested, but the law remained, resulting in an increase in existing tensions between the two nations. Despite the increased tensions, it appeared that the U.S. Congress had decided that preserving the racial composition of the country was more important than promoting good ties with Japan.
The notion of Melting Pot vs Salad Bowl
The USA is traditionally called a melting pot because with time, generations of immigrants have melted together: they have abandoned their cultures to become totally assimilated into American society. Historically, it is often used to describe the assimilation of immigrants to the United States.
But in the UK, where cultural diversity is considered a positive thing, immigrants have always been encouraged to maintain their traditions and their native language. This model of racial integration can be described as a salad bowl, with people of different cultures living in harmony, like the lettuce, tomatoes and carrots in a salad. New York City can be considered as being a “salad bowl”
Both models of multicultural societies have contradictory aspects:
in a melting pot there is no cultural diversity and sometimes differences are not respected;
in a salad bowl cultures do not mix at all.
Present situation
Immigrants comprise about 14 percent of the U.S. population: more than forty-three million out of a total of about 323 million people. Together, immigrants and their U.S.-born children make up about 27 percent of U.S. inhabitants. Illegal immigration. The undocumented population is about eleven million and has leveled off since the 2008 economic crisis, which led some to return to their home countries and discouraged others from coming to the United States. A 2017 Gallup poll found that 71 percent of Americans considered immigration a “good thing” for the United States.
Forty-six percent of immigrants in 2017 reported their race as single-race White, 27 percent as Asian, 9 percent as Black, and 16 percent as some other race. About 2 percent reported having two or more races. In 2017, approximately 78 percent (239.3 million) of the 306 million people ages 5 and older in the United States reported speaking only English at home.
The US at the beginning of the 20th century
Urbanisation (living conditions, labour unions)
The US was a predominantly rural in the 18th century. In 1790 approximately 95% of people lived outside a city. At that time only 3 cities had more than 15.000 residents. However, urbanisation exploded during the Industrial Revolution. The nation changed from an agricultural to an urbanized and industrialized one. Before the Revolution, rich people tended to live in the center of the city. However, rapid urbanization opened the possibilities of larger roads and mass public transport, which allowed towns to expand their borders. Because factory workers did not need to live in a close range to their workplace, suburbs were built. The North became heavily urbanized and industrialized, while the South remained rural. Only in 1920 did the number of citizens living in urban areas become bigger than in rural areas. Because of the growing number of factory workers, more people demanded tolerable working conditions. This marked the rampant start of labour unions. Eventually, labour unions played a key role in abolishing child labour and increasing wages, reducing working hours and improving sanitation in factories across USA.
Progressive Movement: Theodore Roosevelt
The Progressive Movement, also known as Progressive Era, was a period from 1830s to 1920s. The later political movement supported equal conditions for everybody and it developed because of the socio-economic problems as a consequence to industrialization. Many progressives lived in cities and were well educated. Many problems, such as immigration, corruption, better education and the right to vote were tackled. The peak of the activism was when Theodore Roosevelt came to power as president. He was the governor of New York and he was aware of city problems, which only the government could resolve. He noticed the public’s outcry over rising prices in industries controlled by a monopoly. He began to eliminate monopoly, such as in the railroad, tobacco, beef and oil industries. His reforms’ purpose was to allow a free market and to end corruption and monopolism. To add, he claimed a lot of land in the west to harvest resources and develop an infrastructure for citizens. The Progressive Era ended after World War I, when the horrors of people were exposed and many began to associate president Wilson’s sayings with the war. He was the creator of National Pubs in the US.
An American Empire (the Philippines, Cuba)
It was a Spanish-American war. The first battle was held in the Philippines. Americans knew nothing about Philippines culture or history so American military diplomacy was being carried out in the arrogant cover of almost total ignorance. In 1896, a riot against the Spanish had started in the Philippines. The rebels had adopted a constitution modeled after the American constitution. They had elected a government, including a president: Emilio Aguinaldo. Spain agreed on a truce but then tricked the Philippines so America sent their troops to help the rebels out. Rebels didn’t accept the help put the troops never left. Spain knew they were losing so they surrendered, but only to the US. Americans stayed there and from their point of view, Filipinos were a conquered people. They had no right, US troops searched their houses without any warrants. Americans called them “indians” and the soldier referred to them as “niggers”. American soldiers also landed in Cuba. In less than two weeks of fighting, the Spanish were again defeated. Other American soldiers occupied Puerto Rico, another Spanish-owned island close to Cuba. In July the Spanish government saw it was beaten. It asked the Americans for peace.
When peace was signed, Spain gave most of its overseas empire to the United States – Cuba, the Philippines, Puerto Rico and a small Pacific island called Guam. Spain sold the Philippines to America for 20 million dollars. But not everything is bad, the Americans built schools and hospitals, constructed roads, provided pure water supplies and put an end to killer diseases like malaria and yellow fever in the lands they now ruled. They continued to rule most of them until the middle years of the century. The Philippines became an independent country in 1946. In 1953 Puerto Rico became self-governing, but continued to be closely tied to the United States. In 1959 Hawaii was admitted as the fiftieth state of the Union. Cuba was treated differently. When Congress declared war on Spain in 1898 it said that it was only doing so to help the Cuban people to win independence. When the war ended, Cuba was soon declared an independent country. Nevertheless, US used Cuba as a military base.
Dollar Diplomacy
Dollar Diplomacy, foreign policy created by U.S. President William Howard Taft and his secretary of state, Philander C. Knox, to ensure the financial stability of a region while protecting and extending U.S. commercial and financial interests there. It grew out of President Theodore Roosevelt’s peaceful intervention in the Dominican Republic, where U.S. loans had been exchanged for the right to choose the Dominican head of customs (the country’s major revenue source).Under the name of Dollar Diplomacy, the Taft administration engineered such a policy in Nicaragua. It upheld the overthrow of José Santos Zelaya and set up Adolfo Díaz in his place; it set up an authority of traditions; and it ensured loans to the Nicaraguan government. The hatred of the Nicaraguan individuals, however, in the long run resulted in U.S. military intervention too. Taft and Knox also attempted to promulgate Dollar Diplomacy in China, where it was even less successful, both in terms of U.S. ability to supply loans and in terms of world reaction. The dismal failure of Dollar Diplomacy—from its simplistic assessment of social unrest to its formulaic application—caused the Taft administration to finally abandon the policy in 1912. Dollar diplomacy has come to refer in a disparaging way to the heedless manipulation of foreign affairs for strictly monetary ends.
Monroe Doctrine
The Monroe Doctrine was a United States policy of opposing European colonialism in the Americas beginning in 1823. It stated that further efforts by European nations to take control of any independent state in North or South America would be viewed as “the manifestation of an unfriendly disposition toward the United States.” At the same time, the doctrine noted that the U.S. would recognize and not interfere with existing European colonies nor meddle in the internal concerns of European countries. The Doctrine was issued on December 2, 1823 at a time when nearly all Latin American colonies of Spain and Portugal had achieved, or were at the point of gaining, independence from the Portuguese and Spanish Empires. To simplify the Monroe Doctrine was a principle of US policy, originated by President James Monroe, that any intervention by external powers in the politics of the Americas is a potentially hostile act against the US.
The US in WWI
The United States declared war on Germany on April 6, 1917, more than two and a half years after World War I started. Before entering the war, the U.S. had remained neutral, though it had been an important supplier to Great Britain and the other Allied powers.The U.S. made its major contributions in terms of supplies, raw material, and money, starting in 1917. American soldiers under General of the Armies John Pershing, Commander-in-Chief of the American Expeditionary Force (AEF), arrived at the rate of 10,000 men a day on the Western Front in the summer of 1918. During the war the U.S. mobilized over 4 million military personnel and suffered 110,000 deaths, including around 45,000 who died due to the 1918 Spanish influenza outbreak. The war saw a dramatic expansion of the United States government in an effort to harness the war effort and a significant increase in the size of the U.S. Armed Forces.After a relatively slow start in mobilizing the economy and labor force, by spring 1918, the nation was poised to play a role in the conflict. Under the leadership of President Woodrow Wilson, the war represented the climax of the Progressive Era as it sought to bring reform and democracy to the world, although there was substantial public opposition to U.S. entry into the war. Although World War I began in 1914, the United States did not join the war until 1917. The impact of the United States joining the war was significant. The additional firepower, resources, and soldiers of the U.S. helped to tip the balance of the war in favor of the Allies.
Versailles Treaty of 1919
The Treaty of Versailles was perhaps one of the most important treaties in all of mankind, ending the Great War, or better known as World War I. Initially, it originated from President Woodrow Wilson, with his Fourteen Points Speech to the Congress on January 8, 1918. The Treaty was signed on June 28, 1919. Under the Dawes Plan and the Young Plan, Germany was held responsible for all war crimes and damages, therefore they had to pay 132 billion marks (roughly 396 billion euros in today’s economy) in reparations. This was also the cause of the hyperinflation in Germany.
Most of the border territories were either given back to the original country or given as entirely new land for neighbouring countries who aided the Triple Entente (Denmark, Belgium, Poland and Lithuania). The treaty demanded that Germany would lower their armies forces, all while prohibiting the use of certain class weapons and later on, be completely disarmed. However, due to the rise of Hitler in 1932, the treaty’s terms were completely avoided.
League of Nations
The League of Nations was to be formed under the first part of the Treaty of Versailles, later officially founded at the Paris Peace Conference on January 10, 1920. There were 42 original founding members and 15 other countries who joined later on. Its primary goal was to maintain world peace, by negotiation before things got worse. Their most successful achievement was the creation of the Geneva Protocol (prohibited use of biological and chemical weapons), while their other endeavours were not able to be enacted. A lot of problems were not able to be solved because of countries not believing that they were a threat to the attackers, meaning that the League had to mostly watch from the sidelines.
Even though it was Woodrow Wilson’s plan to form an intergovernmental organization to stop wars from ever happening, the US refused to join them. This, and the Soviet Union joining the League and later declaring war on Finland severely lowered their reputation.
During World War II, the League of Nations’ members were supposed to stay neutral, but France and Germany did not agree to this. That shows how low the organization had fallen, and in the early to mid-40’s, it basically ceased to exist. Only 26 of them remained as part of the League until its disbandment in 1946.
Discussion
In the first scenes of the movie, we could see the statue of liberty in the distance. What was its purpose in the context of this movie?
Between 1886 and 1924, almost 14 million immigrants entered the United States through New York. The Statue of Liberty was a reassuring sign that they had arrived in the land of their dreams. To these anxious newcomers, the Statue’s uplifted torch did not suggest “enlightenment,” as her creators intended, but rather, “welcome.” Over time, Liberty emerged as the “Mother of Exiles,” a symbol of hope to generations of immigrants.
As we saw in the movie, Ewa arrived with her sister Magda on the Ellis Island immigrant Station. Why were they there? (where did they come from?) what happened to their other family members? Which wave of immigration did they arrive with?
They migrated from Poland to New York to escape the Great war and look for a better life. Their home was destroyed and parents were killed by soldiers, but their aunt and uncle lived in New York and the sisters were supposed to go and live with them. They arrived with the third wave of immigration.
Why was Ewa worried about her sister’s condition? What happened to her sister?
Ewa was worried that her sister wouldn’t pass the strict medical examinations. When the inspector listened her lungs, he said that she might have tuberculosis and has to be examined further. She would be kept in the Ellis Island hospital for 6 months and if she didn’t improve at that time she would be deported back to Poland.
When Ewa was interviewed, she failed to ask one question. What question? What was the outcome?
The officer asked her if she had committed a crime or not. Ewa said no, but she was told her answer is incorrect. It was written on the papers that on the voyage to America, Eva prostituted herself (the truth, revealed later, is that she was raped). After failing to answer the question, she was sent so be deported back to Poland. (her family’s address was also said to be inexistent).
Why did officers in the Ellis Island call Ewa a girl with low morals?
They thought that she had prostituted herself to the men on the boat. But as it comes out from the movie, this statement is not true at all, she has high morals (as being a Catholic).
How did Bruno have the pull on Ellis Island? (gets to bring immigrants in)
Bruno claims that he has ties with an Immigrant Assistance Organization/Travel’s Aid Company. In reality, money and relationships.
As we all see from the movie, clearly Magda was very important to Ewa. Ewa was determined to help her sister every war she could. What measures was Ewa willing to take purely just to get money and the help her sister needed?
She tried to steal money, starts performing in Bruno’s theatre, prostitution, tolerating Bruno, not leaving from him, helps to cover up a murder.
In the bathhouse, Ewa was offered a banana. She started eating it with the peel on. Explain that.
Many of the immigrants didn’t have the money to afford luxurious ships to travel to America. They had to survive on lukewarm soup, black bread, potatoes, and fish. Exotic foods like bananas were new things to them.
How did Bruno convince Ewa into prostitution?
He invites her to perform in his burlesque show. She can be one of the girls who doesn’t appear nude, he says, but he informs her that, if she really wants to earn the money to bribe the Ellis Island officials to let her sister go, she will have to do certain “things” she won’t want to do.
Why and on what terms did Ewa agree with that?
It was the only way for her to earn money to save her sister. She begins to prostitute herself for Bruno, but only if he gives her half the money.
Does Ewa fit in with the other burlesque girls? Why did Ewa feel misplaced and didn’t connect with the other burlesque girls and characters?
Ewa felt like an outcast among the other burlesque girls, because she was most likely traumatized after leaving her sister and felt alone in that terrible situation. She couldn’t participate in a competition because she didn’t have any money. She also refused to drink with the others. Said she misses her family. The other girls were also jealous that Bruno seemed to like Ewa so much and ultimately fell in love with her.
Rosie mentioned liquor quite many times, what was the situation with alcohol in the states in the 20s? (hint: Al Capone)
The period between 1920 and 1933 in the states is often referred to as “the prohibition era”. Alcoholism, family violence (wife abuse), petty crime and saloon-based political corruption prompted prohibitionists, to end the alcoholic beverage trade to cure the ill society. The Eighteenth Amendment established the prohibition of “intoxicating liquors”. This prompted the rise of speakeasies (illegal bars selling beer and liquor after paying off local police and government officials). Bandit’s Roost was (probably) a speakeasy.
Ewa escapes Bruno’s place and arrives at her aunt’s and uncle’s. How did they act towards her?
Her aunt and uncle accepted her into their home at first, but the next morning her uncle (who was a respected businessman) learned about the rumors on the ship and reported Ewa to the police. He was a man of honour. A good name was important to him. Ewa’s aunt was much more caring, gave Ewa money to help Magda.
The inspector in the Ellis Island told Ewa, that her aunt’s and uncle’s address isn’t valid and doesn’t exist. To Ewa’s uncle they said, that Ewa and Magda never came with the boat. Why did they lie?
The inspector didn’t lie. Ewa’s uncle had been to Ellis Island, but after he heard what had happened on the boat to US (“Ewa had prostituted”), he left. He thinks himself as a business and an honourable man, who doesn’t want to get his name shamed.
Explain the love triangle situation in the movie.
Bruno is madly in love with Ewa. Emil seems to fancy Ewa too, not as desperately as Bruno does. Ewa doesn’t seem to like no one, she is determined to get to her loving sister, and to her, nothing else matters.
Who do you think Ewa would have preffered?
I personally think Ewa wouldn’t have picked either of them but if she had to I would’ve preferred if she picked Emil. But she was very co-dependent to Bruno, maybe she wouldn’t been able to leave him.
Why did Bruno feel jealous of Emil and why was he scared of him?
When they were younger, Emil ran away with bruno’s girlfriend and it hurt him a lot. He was scared that Orlando might come and steal Ewa from him. But Bruno also had a gun in his drawer for protection and he wasn’t afraid to use it.
Why did Emil fail to protect and save Ewa. How did he die?
Orlando comes back from his tour, says that he could help Ewa reach her sister.
They take Bruno’s gun, Emil appears during a conversation between Bruno and Ewa. Orlando forces Bruno to say that Ewa is free to go, threatening him with a gun to his head, but Bruno stabs Orlando at the same time Orlano releases the fake shot because of fear and kills him.
When Ewa went to confess in the church that she stole the money, she talked about her journey to new york. Explain it (the conditions)
“There is no food and no room. It is very dirty and we are all together, like animals.”
What was the importance of Mother of God in the movie? Why did Ewa pray to her?
The heroine prays to Mary in two scenes. In the second scene, however, she also overtly prays to God in the name of the Holy Trinity. At the end, it appears that God has indeed answered her prayers.
What was Bruno’s ethnicity/religion?
Ashkenazi jew, central european (cop called him “kike” which is a slur for a jew, he said he spoke yiddish which is the historical language of Ashkenazi jews). Weiss is a German, Austrian, Swiss German, German Jewish, Austrian Jewish, and Swiss Jewish surname meaning ‘white’ or ‘knows’. Bruno tells Ewa in the beginning of the film, that he speaks Yiddish (a language used mainly by Jews).
What do you think of Ewa’s character development?
Shy and helpless > can stand up for herself, can hold a conversation. hiding behind the fireplace > threatening her coworker w/ scissors. blindly trusting bruno > being sceptical about orlando helping her with her sister. parallelism: the other women giving her opium in the beginning (for her nerves or whatever) > she giving bruno opium (for pain) after he gets beat up.
Why does Ewa thank bruno at the end? Why does bruno not accept her thanks?
Thanks to Bruno, Ewa wasn’t deported back, she ultimately got back together with her sister. Every other bad thing didn’t matter in that second, Ewa was thinking that Bruno’s love for her saved her sister. Bruno felt like he had betrayed Ewa. Because of him, Ewa starts prostitution to earn money. He gave her no other choice.
How is the ending of the movie related to the morale of the story?
the ending of THE IMMIGRANT shows clearly that Christian faith in God leads to salvation and freedom, but a sinful life leads to an impoverished life of psychological imprisonment,(like a Hell).
What do you think happened to Bruno after the sisters sailed back to New York?
He went to the police station to confess his crimes.
What was the relationship between Ewa and Bruno in the beginning. Describe the change. What were Bruno’s intentions with Ewa in the beginning of the film? How did change throughout the film? Why? What changed in Bruno?
In the beginning, Ewa was seen just as a next pretty girl, who could perform in Bruno’s theatre. Ewa trusts Bruno blindly, to help her and hopes that he would help to get her sister out too. Soon Bruno starts falling for Ewa (for some odd reason), Ewa despises him. Because he had led her to prostitution and performing. Bruno starts going crazy, paranoid about Emil, ultimately kills him, saves money for her, gets beat up but still wants to help. In the end Ewa sees that Bruno cares for her and tries to forgive and give him a second chance.
Ewa says this: “I hate you (Bruno), and I hate myself?” What does she mean by it?
Pretty straightforward. Bruno led Ewa to prostitution. Ewa would have never done that if it wasn’t for money. Her morals were too high. She hated herself because she had commited too many sins in terms of her Catholic religion.